The Construction of Space Shuttle Launch Complex 39-B
A very personal and technical written and photographic history, by James MacLaren.
Page 52: A Lighter Moment in a Heavy Place, and a Deep Dive into the Canister Hoisting System.
My
incomplete case of
prosopagnosia means that
some of the time (but not all that often, and it's infuriatingly
random in all instances), faces will be perfectly recognizable to me, and I won't have the least trouble with it, and in the case of the photograph above, we're getting a sterling example of that very thing, and the person you're seeing here across a yawning gulf of
forty years is
Dave Skinner, and of that there can be no doubt whatsoever, because...
incomplete prosopagnosia.
Maybe ask
Oliver Sacks how it works, ok? I sure as hell don't know. Nor do I
suppose myself to know, either. Oliver's
prosopagnosia came with
topographical agnosia, but mine does not, and in fact, as you may have already discovered, following me around via the photographs through the labyrinthine twists and turns of the launch pad, I am
lethally accurate with what I call my "nav skills" and I'll navigate you under the table and down into a hole in the ground if you ever foolishly choose to go up against me with it, so each instance is
different and right there is where we'll give the matter a rest, ok?
Dave was a Union Ironworker out of the Local 808 Union Hall, and worked for Ivey Steel. He had a brother Steve, and the both of them were regular fixtures on the Pad while I was also working for Ivey Steel, and we will be seeing both of them again, more than once, in the coming photographs.
In our photograph, it's early morning, and Dave has spotted me across the way at the 125'-0" level of the RSS, and is indulging himself in a bit of whimsy, mugging for the camera, before pulling his hood back down and continuing with the work of modifying the 125' Floor Steel at the Orbiter Mold Line (I still can't decide if that's a
welding stinger Dave's holding in his right hand, or a
cutting torch, and one of the ropes holding up one of the floats is in
exactly the wrong position to allow me to say, one way or the other, with enough confidence), in preparation for the installation of the OMS Pod Heated Purge covers, which were a
nightmare, and which we will be hearing a LOT more about, soon.
But before we launch off into
those very deep and very dark woods, let's stop and consider what's holding Dave up. What's keeping him from falling to his death.
The floats.
This is probably the best picture in the entire series, for depicting the kind of
floats that Union Ironworkers were in the habit of using, back in the mid 1980's.
Nowadays, the Safety Man would
shut the whole job down if he saw somebody perched above
certain death in this manner, and even though I've been out of touch with all of the practitioners of the craft I used to work with for a pretty good while now, my guess is that, right now, most of the veteran ironworkers you might encounter on a job would rather be doing it the way you see it being done in this photograph, instead of what's being forced on them today.
People freak out when they see this stuff.
Wait a minute, let me
correct that.
People
who do not know, freak out when they see this stuff.
People who, in their entire lives have never been within shooting distance of something like this, and who would
recoil in terror if asked to get out there
on the damn thing and
use it, will
invariably stand there, look you squarely in the eyes with the most sober expression on their faces that you could imagine, and then proceed to
tell you how to DO it, even though
they have no idea whatsoever as to what the hell they're talking
about. No idea at all. None.
Union Ironworkers KNOW.
They know
what works.
And they know WHY it works.
And a
surprising amount of
why has nothing whatsoever to do with the actual, as-it's-being-used
functionality of the thing, but instead revolves around
setting it up, and getting it into position, coupled with
the real-world realities of EXACTLY how safe it is, and whether or not that safety can be,
real-world, improved by doing it some other way.
And of course that "some other way" part of things is where you wind up getting
hurt, following directives given by
people who do not know what the hell they're talking about.
The ropes are
fine, as-is. They
never fail. Nobody
ever falls. EVER.
The wooden platform of the float itself is
fine, as-is. They
never fail. Nobody
ever falls. EVER.
And the whole
system is
fine, as-is. It
never fails. Nobody
ever falls. EVER.
Do you
really think you know
more about what Dave is doing than Dave knows about it himself?
Really?
My guess is that Dave would laugh right out loud in your face if you tried to tell him something like that.
In. Your. Face.
Dave's not getting on the sonofabitch unless and until
DAVE considers it fit and proper for the purposes of holding him up, mid-air, in an otherwise
completely unreachable location, in a way that can be
guaranteed to keep him safe while he's up there.
So get a good gander at
what works, maybe. Try to
learn from what you're seeing, maybe.
It looks
light, and it
is, but it's plenty heavy enough, and that
lightness translates
directly into ease of
setting it up, getting it into place, and just generally being able to
manipulate things, in the
safest manner possible.
And it's also remarkably
simple, and easy to understand, which makes for a
vastly better and more-complete grasp of things, with
less crap to have to consider, when you're giving it the looking-over it gets
every time before it gets used.
And it also makes for less bullshit to have to go through as you're setting it up, which makes for
less time spent and
less work done, which of course are yet
more very good reasons for doing it this way.
Don't cost much money, either.
So ok. So this is how it's done. By the people who
know how it all works, better than anybody else in the world.
And as for the absurd "safety line" around Dave's waist, that thing is strictly "eyewash" and beyond keeping somebody from raising a howl over it, it really has no proper function.
The ironworkers, with certain very specific instances and exceptions, didn't have much use for "safety lines" either.
Just another goddamned thing to get tangled up in, or snagged on in a hidden place, with a
very real potential for hurting you or even
killing you, and if you're not comfortable getting around up here without one, maybe you shouldn't be up here in the first place?
I recall more than one
battle, with different Safety Departments, in different organizations, on different launch pads, and it was a huge pain in the ass. Every. Single. Time.
People with soft skin, in button-down shirts and well-polished shoes, sitting behind desks,
issuing directives about safety lines, safety harnesses, and safety god-knows-what-else...
none of which any of them had ever used for themselves, or had the faintest idea as to how it really
worked, in the real world,
up on the iron.
And they would dig in their heels, and we would dig in our heels, and the paper would fly, and the meetings would be held, and the ironworkers would just
ignore the stupidity of it all and go right on
getting it done, doing it
right, and...
Ye gods! Parts of the job were no fun at all.
Somewhere, in the fetid air down at the very bottom of it... I can smell
lawyers.
And of course
everybody knows that there can be no better possible judge of what's safest, and what works best, up on high steel, than a goddamned
lawyer, right?
Feh.
Ok. So what's going on with the tower in this image?
I mentioned modifications work for the OMS Pods Heated Purge Covers a little while ago, so let's familiarize ourselves by taking a closer look at some of that kind of stuff, ok?
We've already met the Orbiter Mold Line in several places, some
high and some
low, and we've been exposed to how it dictates the
shape of the steel at the edges of the platform framing in the areas on the RSS that abut the Orbiter (or very
nearly abut, since nothing actually
touches the orbiter), but despite the fact that
we've already encountered some bizarrely-complex aspects to it, we still really haven't
fully plumbed the depths of this stuff yet, and our photograph up at the top of this page is one of the very best looks at
one of these areas, so let's dig down into it for real, right now, ok?
Just to review, let us return to a 79K04400
Pad A drawing (Mind the elevations, and we're using the A Pad drawing to show you these curves because we don't have an equivalent drawing for Pad B, but it's the same places, ok?) that uses a little
Descriptive Geometry to show
the Orbiter Mold Line at each end of the Payload Bay, just as a reminder of how tricky these
curves really are, once you actually have to break out the torches and clamps and welding gear down on the shop floor, and
make the goddamned thing, starting out with
steel shapes, that you get from the steel mill,
board-straight, ok?
For
these two areas only, they give us the curve in exquisite detail, and that's because in these two areas, only (well... excepting the Side Seal Panels, but they're straight as an arrow, having no curve to them at all), something
will be touching the Orbiter, and even though it's only a very light and delicate
Inflatable Seal, they still wanted to be damn good and sure they got the
shape of the thing, exactly right, and so they went the extra mile with it, and produced these drawings with the curves
nailed down, so that there could be no chance whatsoever for a
mistake in this area.
But of course
there's a story. There's
always a story, right?
In the beginning... they weren't quite so sure about it, and so, not quite
really knowing what the hell was going to be happening when their four-million-pound
steel hotel came swinging around like a battleship to within a gnat's whisker of their multi-billion-dollar
spaceship for the very first time, they decided to err on the side of caution just a little bit.
Observe.
This is the original
Pad A incarnation of things down on the APU Servicing Platform at the 120'-0" level (mind those Pad A elevations), which is where we see Dave Skinner happily mugging for my camera in the photograph at the top of this page,
at Pad B.
Let's zoom in on the drawing, to just
the area we're interested in, showing us the floor steel in the area around the Orbiter Mold Line.
Where we discover, that originally,
since they weren't quite sure about it, they specified that the floor perimeter steel at the Orbiter Mold Line be
curved, in close agreement with the outline of the Space Shuttle's OMS Pods at this elevation on the tower, but they did it a funny way, with a note involving a different drawing, so let's go to the different drawing, and get to the bottom of the matter thereby.
79K04400 S-61.
And get a look at highlighted Note A, where it says "...compound curve in plan view. Exact dimensions will be furnished after award of contract..."
So clearly, when they were getting ready to
build the RSS over on Pad A, they
still hadn't quite decided on what to do with this stuff facing the Orbiter Mold Line down near the bottom of things at the APS Servicing Platform level and also at the APU Servicing Platform level.
Which of course didn't actually
stop them, but it
did put a little bump in the road right here.
All well and good, and however it wound up getting built over at A Pad (I was not around at the time, so I have no idea how it all went down), that's how it got built, but in the intervening period of time between my days on Pad B with Sheffield Steel, and my days on Pad B with Ivey Steel...
...
things changed.
Slow-dawning realization that the
Orbiter was not as robust,
nor as safe, as they originally persuaded themselves to believe it was...
...was ever-so-creepingly beginning to set in, and with that creeping realization setting in...
...they also realized that they were going to have to
modify things out on the pads to accommodate their
altered understanding of their
Space Shuttle...
...and this revealed itself to be a
very dark hole, which, when they at first discovered it, and then ever-so-cautiously entered it and then began exploring it; and it expanded and branched out unexpectedly on them, into a bewildering labyrinth of ever-deeper side-tunnels and galleries which
themselves continued to branch out in unexpected ways, growing and ramifying more and more, the farther they went down and into the clinging darkness of things.
And
the whole thing was given a name, and that name was "
Orbiter Weather Protection," and we're going to be going a pretty good ways down and into this very dark and very complex hole ourselves,
but not all the way, because I left the Pad before it was all
finally said and done with, and I did not participate in the culmination of things as they reached their final configuration, which final configuration wrapped itself around great tracts of both the RSS and the FSS and
altered the look of the Pad mightily.
And so, right now, we find ourselves, looking at our photograph up at the top of this page,
just dipping our toe into this
very deep and also
very dark water.
And what I just gave you is a bit of
foreshadowing only, and soon enough we will be well and truly
immersed in things, but for now, let us return to the Orbiter Mold Line down at the 125'-0" elevation on Pad B, and see how things came to take on the look you're seeing when you look at the photograph on the top of this page.
And please keep in mind that, as we ponder no end of very-curious-looking
curves in certain parts of the floor framing down here, we're dealing with those curves because this is the area where the the RSS meets the Space Shuttle's OMS Pods, and those OMS Pods have a devilishly-complex three-dimensionally
curved outline, and we're going to be
dealing with it, as we deal with our
steel in this area.
Here's what we're having to deal with.
And here it is again.
And once more, just to make sure you can really
visualize this stuff.
They
originally spec'd out those curves, over on Pad A, down at the APU Servicing Platform level, which is the second-to-lowest main level on the RSS, and below that, down at the very lowest main level of the RSS, on the APS Servicing Platform Level, and those very same
curves made it over to Pad
B, when I was there, working for Sheffield, and we can see the curve at elevation 125'-0", where Dave Skinner is working, as it was
originally furnished an installed, in some of the photographs I took when I worked for Sheffield.
None of these images are particularly
good for the purposes of showing you the curved steel that was originally furnished and installed on Pad B, complete with a Compressible Bumper on it,
but it's there, and you can
see it. Its main distinguishing feature is that, unlike the steel at the next level down, at 112'-0", as you travel along the curve toward the centerline of the RSS, the curve comes all the way around, and begins to double back on itself, and in the areas closest to the centerline of the RSS on either side, closest to where the Orbiter's Tail would be located, it comes to a very distinct and noticeable
point.
We'll look at things again, on the Pad A drawings, just to make sure you can
visualize it, and distinguish the
APU Servicing Platform curved and "pointed" steel, from the
very-similar, curved but "unpointed," steel below it, down at the APS Servicing Platform. Be sure to click the images to bring them up full-size, ok? The "points" on the curved steel at the APU Servicing Platform are not shown particularly well on the drawing, but there is
clearly a noticeable difference between the elevations, once you're on to it, and once you know exactly what to look for.
Click the following photographs for full-size, and then look
closely at the 125'-0" elevation (which by now you are presumed to be able to
locate, on your own) in the Orbiter Mold Line area.
We'll start by looking up at it, from the ground.
And then we'll look down at it from above, even though it's almost completely incomprehensible, with a
very obstructed view, but
if we highlight it, we can see things with surprising clarity,
especially the areas where the curve doubles back around on itself into a "point,"
And then one last time, from below again, but from nearby, looking up from the APS Servicing Platform beneath it, down at elevation 112'-0", where we can see
part of it, directly beneath the folded-down Canister Access Platform and the guy handling the air line on the other side of the safety chains directly behind it, but not the part with the "point" on it.
So ok, so that's how they did it back in the beginning. What's the big deal, anyway?
And the big deal is that we're getting a near-perfect easy-to-digest, introduction into a hugely-complicated thing that wound up utterly altering the
look of the towers. And which is a
right bastard to understand the bizarrely-interlocking and extraordinarily-complex full details of.
And not only that, but by beating the living hell out of this thing down here, I'm also, sneakily, causing those of you who are actually
clicking the links and
attempting to understand (and of course everybody else
jumped ship somewhere back in the middle of
Page 1 and no, the rest of us do
not miss them, actually), to build up some pretty good
muscle memory as regards developing a sensible gut-feeling for what the place looks like down here. Which we're very definitely
going to need as we plumb the depths, further and further into the world of
Orbiter Weather Protection. Into the world of OWP, as it descends upon us from a starting point which is literally and structurally
above the roof of the RCS Room.
And
you've already seen it, but I'm guessing that none of you have actually
noticed it...
...what?
The first hint of the coming OWP
modifications down here. Down low.
And owing to the vagaries of history, and
things that pass through the eyes of needles, we find ourselves having to flip back and forth between the Pad A drawings and the Pad B drawings, but, as if by a miracle,
the very first alterations, down here at 125'-0",
have been preserved, and we get to
see them.
Back to the zoomed-in Pad A version of
what it looks like down here at the APU Servicing Platform.
And now to the zoomed-in Pad B version of
what it looks like down here at the APU Servicing Platform.
Anything kind of...
catching your eye there?
Any...
discrepancy maybe?
Open 'em both up in different tabs and blink back and forth between them.
And
now you can
see that the entire curved cutout area, the entire
space that will be filled up with the OMS Pods when the RSS is
mated with the Space Shuttle at the level of the APU Servicing Platform...
...has gotten MUCH larger on the B Pad drawing than it was on the A Pad drawing.
MUCH larger.
And if you look
closely, you suddenly realize that on Pad B, it's not even
curved anymore!
It's a series of
straight C8x11.5
segments, and not a curve to be found, anywhere!
So what happened? What
changed? Luck was very definitely with us when The Fates decreed that the
changes that are manifest on the Pad B drawing,
never got incorporated into the Pad A drawing. And we're closing in on
another bizarre twist of fate regarding "what got incorporated into the drawings" as compared to "what did not get incorporated into the drawings"... but not yet. Not right now. But soon. Soon enough.
For the moment, we've been given a miraculous periscope into a long-forgotten past...
...where
things were changing.
And we can see on the Pad B drawing, on 79K14110 drawing S-32, how they did it.
We can see that they eliminated the
curve by cutting the floor steel back, and breaking the area where the enlarged curve would be, into a group of small-enough arrow-straight bits, called out a whole series of
"rise over run" numbers for each bit, and wound up with a perfectly acceptable
shape and avoided a whole bunch of over-fussy and over-expensive fabrication and erection bullshit in the process.
And then you
go back to our photograph and give it a click to zoom it in full-size, and sure enough,
every single bit of that Orbiter Mold Line steel which Dave has his left hand on, is
straight segments of C8x11.5 welded together end-to-end and there's not a
curve to be seen on
any of it.
Makes perfect sense to me.
And our photograph serves as a sterling example of the fact that Ivey Steel
hit the ground running, once they'd been awarded this contract.
This is only the
second photograph in Part 2, and yet the floor steel at elevation 125'-0" had already been cut back and reworked, to an almost fully-finished configuration, before I ever managed to get up here with my camera for the first time and start taking pictures once again.
Compare this area with
our very first image in Part 2, where you can see that this whole area remains
untouched.
But it sure as hell didn't
stay that way for very long, and here we are looking at yet another excellent example of just how
fast Union Ironworkers get things done.
But
why?
Why did they enlarge the cutout area down here at 125'-0" so much?
Did somebody come along and greatly enlarge the Space Shuttle's
OMS Pods? And eliminate the curves which make up their overall shape and replace them with straight-line segments while they were doing it?
Of course not.
So what's going on here, anyway?
And it turns out to be the same thing that caused them to butcher the floor steel one level up, on the RSS Main Floor at 135'-7", even as they left the floor steel one level down, on the APS Servicing Platform at 112'-0"
completely untouched.
And it turned out that they needed
more room for the damnable OMS Pod Heated Purge Covers, down here at 125'-0", and farther up at 135'-7", but not farther down at 112'-0", and
we're almost there...
...
but not yet.
And this set of
modifications is only the tip of what turned out to be a VERY large iceberg, and in addition to what we've seen so far about the need for more space that dictated they cut the floor steel back at 125 and 135 and rebuild it with a different
configuration...
...there's a whole separate
operational discipline, a whole separate
element to things, represented by one other
item of interest in our photograph, and I may as well deal with it right now, because this is by far our best image of that item,
pre-modification, so ok, let's go.
And our item of interest is
this little guy right here.
A hand-operated winch, painted red, mounted on a stub column which is not properly visible on our photograph, but that's ok, we can live without the stub column for the moment.
And it's part of the
Canister Hoisting System, and it's surprisingly complicated all by itself, and what they wound up doing with it after our photograph was taken is also surprisingly complicated, and we're going to be taking a little
journey.
And our photograph showing us the winch is an excellent starting point, and in conjunction with the drawings, I'm going to lead you along the pathway of the Canister Hoisting System.
And our little red winch was mounted on a peculiar back-to-back double-channel 8x11.5 support column that ties directly to the
RSS Main Framing at its top, and the floor steel at its bottom, with an even more peculiar double
WT 3x12.5 angled brace that came down from above, and met the double-channel column in the middle, right behind where the winch sat over on the other side of the column.
Like this.
And there were
two of these winches and they worked in tandem, one on either side of the centerline of the RSS (and the centerline of the Canister when it was being lifted, too), and you go looking at that drawing again, and you realize...
...these things were pretty sturdy.
And very reasonably so, considering the job they had to do,
pulling the Canister into line.
The wire rope that came off the winch did not go straight to the Canister, and instead went through an equally-sturdy double-sheave that hung down from above, in front of the winch, and it only went to the Canister after it passed through that sheave.
Here's the double-sheave.And
here's the attach hardware it used to attach to the top,
and the bottom, of the Canister when they were using it.
Sturdy enough, I guess.
And its job was to
steady the Canister, and to also
guide it some, as they raised and lowered the Canister into position (using the 90-ton Hoist, which is VASTLY stronger), to a position where it's suspended against the face of the RSS and firmly locked down in that position, where they could open the PCR Doors, and open the Canister Doors, and then remove the payload(s) for the next Space Shuttle mission from the Canister, and get 'em all nice and hung on the PGHM, and then close the PCR Doors and the Canister Doors, before they took the now-empty Canister down to the ground, on its Transporter, which drove it away, and then they would swing the RSS around and mate it with the Space Shuttle (which had already been rolled to the pad), at which point the process would be
reversed and the payloads being held by the PGHM would be rolled forward past the once-again-opened PCR Doors, and the now-open Space Shuttle Payload Bay Doors, and get placed into the Shuttle's Payload Bay, and then they'd roll the PGHM back and close all the doors and demate the RSS to get it out of the way, and they'd be ready to go fly.
And
the Canister was BIG, and it was HEAVY, and when you're
steadying or
guiding or maybe a little bit of both, by yanking on something that's 65 feet long and weighs up to 140,000 pounds...
...sometimes
it yanks back, and if it does, you better be
ready for it, and of course one of the ways you be ready for it is to make
all of your hardware that's involved with it nice and strong.
And that's exactly what they did with this stuff. They made all of it nice and strong.
And now for the
journey.
Hold on to your hats, because here we go.
We will ignore what they did with the Canister when it was away from the Pad, ok?
Not part of my job description.
Not gonna get into it.
The put the
payload inside the Canister, put the Canister on top of its Transporter, standing on end, and drove it out to the Pad, where they parked the Transporter beneath the RSS, and
went to work.
Which is where we will pick up the story, ok?
And it seems easy enough on the surface of things, but then again doesn't
everything?
Which of course is why
idiots who cannot even run their own miserable and worthless lives successfully, blithely believe themselves capable of running
the whole country successfully, even though they are... complete idiots. Or, more likely,
because they are complete idiots.
And it's only when it's
you that's sweating through
the details of making something serious and high-risk happen, correctly, that the full complexities start to weigh down on you.
And when it comes to
lifts, and
heavy lifts in particular, oh hell yes you can bet your ass that no end of sneaky stuff (not such a small amount of which can be
fatal if dealt with incorrectly, or not dealt with at all), starts jumping out of the woodwork at you, and you must account for
all of it, or run the risk of suffering
dire consequences.
And later on in Part 2, we're going to be seeing several nice pictures I took of the Canister for myself, but right now, we'll use some public-domain NASA pictures to show it to you, ok?
So ok.
So
Payload Canister.
And its
Transporter.
And as you can see in the NASA photograph just above, with the Canister beneath the RSS nicely lit up at nighttime, things start out simply enough with the Canister on its Transporter, plumb, square, true, and level, and every bit of that stands to reason, but it's
what happens next that throws everything into a cocked hat, and causes people to have trouble understanding
what the hell it is that they're doing, and
why they would do it, and then everything that follows becomes equally murky and incomprehensible, and once again, I find myself as a lone voice crying in the wilderness, because
nowhere can I find a simple and straightforward explanation
of the whole operation, where all the weirdness is tied together to make it plain and simple enough to understand (and
really, once you get the
sense of it, it's pretty straightforward stuff, and plenty easy enough to understand by pretty much
anybody), so, using
the drawings that's exactly what I'm going to try to do here, ok?
And the
first thing they do, once they're positioned correctly beneath the RSS (there's marks on the concrete to help 'em with that, just like the marks on the concrete at the airport where they park the planes at the gates), is to tilt the bed on the Transporter
down in front, which then
tips the whole Canister well forward, till it's looking like
the Leaning Tower of Pisa.
Here's
a picture of it on the ground, on its Transporter, tilted over, but there aren't really any
good photographs of it, which show it tilted over clearly.
Here's another one, and again, it's not so good, but at least you can see the Transporter "kneeling down" in front pretty well. And since these photos are none too wonderful, we're going to go to one of the drawings, but be careful, 'cause this drawing includes the Canister in
FOUR different positions during the lift operations, and it can really throw you for a loop, if you're not fully aware, and I'm going to color it up to make it easier to understand, but even then,
when it comes to the lines and rigging, it's still pretty tricky, so take it slow with this stuff, ok?
Here you go, drawing
M-149, which is the general arrangement drawing, colored to show the Canister and Transporter in their
initial positions, with the Transporter kneeling down in front, and the Canister tipped forward looking like the Leaning Tower of Pisa, just before they start pulling it up into the air, and in addition to showing you the Canister in
4 separate positions, it does so from
TWO different viewpoints, one from the side (on the left side of the drawing) and one looking straight at it from behind, facing the RSS square-on (on the right side of the drawing), and yeah, it's nice that they've learned how to pack incredible amounts of information into
single engineering drawings, but
sometimes...
And why in the name of hell are they
tipping that Canister forward like that?.
That doesn't just look weird, it looks
dangerous.
Like they're risking tipping it all the way over and having it come crashing down to the ground.
So..... WHY?
Why do that?
And it comes down to some of that
sneaky stuff I mentioned just a minute ago, when we're doing
heavy lifts.
And maybe we'll introduce the subject by letting Michael E. Donahue of PRC
tell you all about it.
And basically, that "kicking-out" which Michael just mentioned is a serious concern during heavy lifts, and when the load goes from being supported by whatever it's resting on, to being suspended by whatever's
lifting it, you can
rely on the fact that everything is
never going to be aligned
perfectly, and it's that imperfect alignment that you're
always going to be dealing with that causes the
problem, and the problem is that at the moment the load enters a state of free suspension,
it's going to "kick" off to the side in some never-quite-exactly-measurable-in-advance way, and if you've got something
big, and
heavy, you better
look out, because it just might
go right through something as it potentially lurches off to the side, and if that's not enough, and if the "kick" is enough, it can start
swinging like a pendulum, and all sorts of truly
terrible things can then start happening, and...
this is an issue with all heavy lifts of stuff that enters the lift without constraint, by freely-moving across the ground to wherever the
pick is going to be made, which also has unique characteristics, each time, of differing precise weights and precise centers of mass, and our Payload Canister most very definitely falls squarely under this heading.
If you've ever seen video of a crane toppling over, it's often enough because the suspended load lurched off to the side as it entered its state of suspension, and just as soon as that happens, the whole center of gravity of the crane boom along with its suspended load has
moved, and if it
moves into a zone where the crane can no longer have enough counterweighted leverage to
resist the power of the
repositioned load pulling on it with
huge force...
And people get
killed.
And astonishingly-expensive equipment and material gets destroyed.
And this is
serious business. Every time you make a lift.
And so, out on the Pad, they
control for this as best they can by tilting the Canister forward to get its center of gravity, as close as they can, lined up with the Lifting
Trunnions they hook on, up at the top of the Canister, and those are
off center!
Why?
Why off center?
Why moved over to the side of things by a significant amount (go back to
M-149 again, and take a closer look at the side view on the left side of the drawing, at the exact location where they're showing the lifting line connecting to the Canister) to a place that causes the Canister to hang in free suspension at a funny top-forward angle, with the bottom of the Canister leaning out,
away from the RSS?
And of course more sneakiness with heavy lifts, and when you're in the middle of a lift, and the wind is blowing, even with tag lines (more on that in just a bit), your suspended load is going to be
moving around some.
Well ok then, if it
must move, how 'bout we fix things up so that the bottom end of our 65-foot-long 140,000 pound object is maybe
a little farther away from our steel structure, than it might be otherwise? So it doesn't kind of, maybe, just a little bit, by accident, we didn't mean it, honest,
bang into something on the way up?
Which is exactly what they do.
It's all about clearances and safety factors and
forgiveness in case things take an
excursion that perhaps we didn't want them to, and perhaps didn't
expect them too,
just in case.
And so they kneel the front end of the Transporter down, and jack the back end of it up, and the Canister tilts
forward and they hook the big spreader beam that's being carried by the 90-ton Payload Hoist to the Lifting Trunnions that were, by design, placed off-center on the top of the Canister, and okey dokey, looks good to me, so let us proceed with things from here, ok?
And proceeding with things takes us directly to the Canister itself, because we're going be encountering things up on the iron that interface and interact directly with the Canister, which of course has it's
own stuff for interfacing and interacting, so now it's time to go look at the Canister in a little more detail, and see what's what, with all
that stuff.
So here's a .pdf file with
a set of simple-enough drawings that give us a pretty good feel for the basic elements of the Canister as a whole.
And I'm going to extract one drawing in particular, giving us side views of the Canister,
so you can more-clearly see what we're about to be getting into with this stuff, but be careful, 'cause they're pointing out the "Outrigger" but in fact, what they're pointing to is the
Guide Shoe (hang on, we'll get to it, and it's
important, so take note of it), which is
supported by the Outrigger, which, strictly-speaking,
is a separate thing from the Guide Shoe. So be warned, ok?
And then here's another .pdf file that gives us
a really good written description of the Canister, and what's going on with it (and this is a
really good document, and it's not too long, and I highly recommend you read it.
And now that we've read the document (We
have, haven't we, hmm?),
here's a labeled photograph showing us what's what, on the
starboard side of the Canister, just like how I've highlighted it in the drawing,
with the outrigger folded down.
And
here's another labeled photograph, also showing the starboard side of the Canister, with the outrigger
extended, showing us what it looks like with things ready-to-go, just about time to attach the lifting gear and "get up on it" and start the lift.
And now that we've just learned how our suspended load is going to
move around some, while it's in the air... And it's not just the breeze doing that, either, sometimes it's the lifting lines. The wire ropes themselves, hanging down from the lifting sheaves and attached to the hook down at the bottom end of things, and those lines will sometimes, as they go from being free-hanging slack to being fully load-bearing the moment the load breaks contact with the ground, want to impart a little
twist, or spin, into our suspended load, and we're going to need to keep
that under control too, so, once again, there's a
lot of sneaky stuff going on as we're lifting, and it's all wanting to
do stuff to our suspended load that we do
not want it to do, and so for these (and there's even
more but let's give it a rest, shall we?) reasons, we attach
tag lines to the bottom end of our load, to pull on it with, and keep it from
going somewhere that we don't want it to go.
And we'll return to M-149 to see this, but I'm going to have to doctor it up some, or otherwise it's going to be way more confusing than we'd like, so kind of keep that in mind too, and as we proceed upwards with our lift (Remember the
red winch in our photograph up at the top of this page? Remember that thing? We're eventually going to get far enough into our Canister Lift to be
using that thing, which is the reason why we launched off into the very thick underbrush we find ourselves bushwhacking through right now, so hang in there, I'll tie it all back together, but we have a ways yet to go, before I can do that.) I'm going to be
altering M-149 appropriately, at each step along the way, ok?
But first,
here's the unaltered version of M-149, so you'll have it to compare with the
altered version, and after working with the altered version a bit, you'll find that if you come back here to the unaltered one, it becomes
much easier to understand.
So here we go with an
altered M-149, showing us the Tag Lines they use to stabilize the Canister during the lift. And although it's
still a little hard to visualize (especially that line coming off of Capstan 2 out of the plane of the drawing,
in our direction at an angle, heading off to a distant snatch block setup which is sitting
between us and the Canister as we view things with M-149, before it changes direction at the snatch block, now heading
straight down into the plane of the drawing, down and over the end of the Transporter, and from there to the bottom of the Canister), but with a "ground level" view, we get a good feel for how the left and right Tag Lines, coming off of Capstans 1 and 3, can pull the Canister
horizontally down on its bottom end to keep it from drifting and twisting (and to also maybe
deliberately put a little drift and/or twist into it if we might ever need to). And oh yeah, we can kind of see how, when it comes to tag lines putting our desired
horizontal forces on something, the farther away we get from the something in question the better (within reason, of course), because the farther away you get, the more
horizontal the direction the tag line takes, from one end to the other.
And
now we can look straight down on it from above, in
plan view and see how Capstan 2 got moved completely out of the way, over next to Capstan 3, and we let
the Snatch Blocks tie our Tag Line to the Canister, instead of doing it directly off the Capstan, like we do it with Capstans 1 and 3.
And the reason they couldn't put Capstan 2 out there in the middle of the Pad Deck, dispensing with the need for the snatch blocks, is because in order to get it far enough away, they wound up in the middle of the Crawlerway, and a Capstan sitting out there right in the middle of Crawlerway might not be such a good idea, when it comes time to use the Crawler to roll the next Space Shuttle out to the Pad, so they said, "Ok,
let's put Capstan 2 over on the ground, right next to the base of the Hinge Column where Capstan 3 is welded on to it, and we'll use
embeds in the Crawlerway and attach a
pair of Snatch Blocks to 'em whenever we need 'em (and yes, owing to the ways in which
running lines, that are
under load, work with a load that's
changing its position with respect to the snatch blocks, it needs to be a
pair of snatch blocks), and that way we can work the Tag Line from Capstan 2 off of the Snatch Blocks and we'll be able to keep the Crawlerway clear for the Crawler, the next time we need to use it."
And now, finally, with the Tag Lines attached at the bottom of the Canister, and the big Spreader Beam which is hanging from the 90-ton Hoist Hook, ready to be attached to the Forward Lifting Trunnions on the top of the Canister, we're
almost ready to lift the Canister.
Whatta ya mean,
almost?
What the hell else do you need to be
doing with the damn thing, anyway?
You're hooked on to it. You're hooked on to it
all over the place. What the hell else are you going to be hooking on to it now? What else even
is there?
And
we've already been here before, back on
Page 32 in Part 1 during my Sheffield Steel days, but at the time we had plenty of other fish to fry, and we did not get into it, but now we will, ok?
We're gonna get to use the
Canister Access Platform. We're gonna get to
walk the plank. But at least this time, there's going to be a great big Payload Canister out there to stand on, just off the end of the plank, instead of the shark-infested waters around a pirate ship.
And oh, by the way, while we're here, we also get a
Bonus View of the Double-sheave Assembly that the wire rope coming off the Winch goes through, on its way to the Canister, complete with a bit of wire rope dangling down from where it's been reeved over the bottom sheave of the Double-sheave Assembly, but I'm pretty sure that's not the
actual wire rope that goes with this thing, and is instead just a little something that the ironworkers tossed in there to give the winch and sheaves a bit of a functional test to make sure it actually
works, after they installed it, 'cause the wire rope in this image has no
fitting on the end. No open spelter socket with a detent pin on a lanyard, which is not the sort of thing one puts on as an afterthought,
in the field.
And I even linked to the drawing for it, back on Page 32,
and hit it with a little highlighting, and gave you
the most cursory possible description of and for it, and then moved on and that was the end of that.
And please note, that from where I was located, as I took
the photograph at the top of this page, I was almost standing
right on top of where the thing had previously been located, prior to the hatchetings which the 125'-0" floor steel underwent in preparations for the installation of the evil OMS Pods Heated Purge Covers.
And we're gonna return to that same already-highlighted drawing again, but this time we're going to dig down a little deeper into this thing.
And we're returning to a drawing of
a thing that no longer even exists in the photograph at the top of this page, because that drawing also, as part of letting you know how the Canister Access Platform works, depicts
the Canister, unlike the drawing of the double flip-up platform that replaced it, and dammit, here I go again, ricocheting off into yet another only-partially-related-tangent, and I need to tell you that between my finishing of Part 1, and my starting in on the writing for Part 2,
impossibly, as if by a miracle, the Long Lost 79K24048 Structural Drawings (some of the 79K24048 Electrical drawings had already fallen into my hands previously, and yes, you can find a very few of them sprinkled amongst Part 1, but they were not nearly enough To Tell The Tale), fell out of the sky, directly into my lap, and how in the name of all holy hell does this stuff just keep happening to me, anyway?
And the main point of
this ricochet is to advise you that 79K24048 (which was produced by the Two-Headed-Monster of PRC/BRPH, which was a joint venture that was apparently concocted-up specifically for just
this project), is, with just a very few exceptions, not
nearly as good as what you've grown used to (and what I had grown used to also) with 79K04400, 79K10338, and 79K14110, all of which were done by RS&H, and all of which are
much better in no end of obvious, and not-so-obvious ways. So fair warning, we're about to enter a realm where the
engineering drawings are not as good as those we've grown accustomed to.
Phew.
Now... where were we?
Oh yeah, the already-demolished Canister Access Platform, which is depicted on
a better drawing, which drawing we're about to use in order to understand how the hell did they lift that goddamned Canister into place, anyway?
Observe.
So we roll the Canister into position, get the Tag Lines on it, lower the Canister Access Platform down on top of it, walk out there on top of it, and from out there on top of it (Are you securely tied off with your safety harness and safety line properly and correctly in place? Don't step in the hole, ok?) we can attach the Lifting Gear from the 90-ton Hoist to the Forward Lifting Trunnions, including the integrally-attached 5-foot sling for the Adjusting Gear from our little red winch, which goes to a place on the Lifting Gear which we saw on the drawing that's just above the Trunnions.
And then of course, once all that attaching is done, we get the hell off the top of the Canister and raise the Access Platform back up into its stowed and locked position where it's out of the way, and
finally, the Canister is ready to go.
And
here's the drawing once again, highlighted this time, now that you have a better idea of what you're seeing, and what it's for, that shows us what
that looks like once it's all put together up there.
And just to review, again, ('cause it's
tricky, right?) what we're seeing here on the drawing is that the big Cable Connectors to the Spreader Bar, the stuff that actually
lifts the Canister, all 140,000 pounds of it, also have, integrally attached to them, five foot slings which we can then, once we're properly on the Lifting Trunnions, attach to our little winch. The
red one. The one we saw in the photograph up at the top of this page. The one that
started all this
Canister stuff we've been talking about for just about forever now. And which we're
still not done with.
Gah.
And now at last, the person with a nice clear view of things
who's standing next to where the Canister Hoist Control Station is mounted, at elevation 125'-0" on the APU Servicing Platform
next to the column out on front side of the RSS at Line B.7-3.4, who is controlling the operation of the 90-ton Hoist, is given the signal to proceed, and all the way up on top of the RSS, inside the Hoist Equipment Room, on its mount above the floor up there at elevation 212'-1", the Hoist Drum starts to turn... slowly... nice and slowly at first, and the lines go taut, and everything creaks and pings and maybe even pops a few times, and way down at the other end of the lines, directly in front of and below the person on the controls, the Canister comes to life,
and starts moving.
And we're going to stop right here, and show you the scene, and we're going to use a drawing we've encountered before, back in Part 1 when we were up in the RCS Room, but this time I'm going to
alter it, and I'm
altering it for the same reason I altered M-149, because in it's unaltered state it's showing the Canister in
FOUR places, so it's showing you
too much, so I'm going to clean it up to give you a sporting chance of actually
understanding what the hell's going on here, right at the exact moment the Canister
comes alive.
And
here's M-143 in its confusingly-unaltered state.
And
here it is all nice and scrubbed clean (at least over on the left side where we're seeing things in "profile" view instead of "face-on", anyway) and labeled-up, showing you exactly what things looked like at the moment they put tension on the 90-ton Hoist lines, and
the lift began.
Open 'em
both up, in separate tabs, and flip back and forth between them, getting a feel for it. And while you're at it, maybe pay a little attention, in the
unaltered version of M-143, to that lifting line coming down from the Head Sheaves up in the rafters of the RCS Room at elevation 238'-6", the one with the Cable Connectors down at the very bottom of it, which are what actually
connects to the Lifting Trunnion on the Canister, and notice if you will, in that
unaltered drawing, there seems to be
TWO of 'em, and they're
offset at an angle, just a wee little bit, and what's
that all about, hmm?
In a minute. Hang on, ok?
And in our
altered drawing, our little red winch (we already learned that there's actually two of 'em, and
it matters, and I'm just about done speaking in the singular, which I've been doing so far, just to try and simplify a little) is right there, hooked on, and the half-inch cable coming off of it to the bottom of the big Cable Connector that hooks on to the Lifting Trunnion is drawn
dead straight, like it's in full
tension, but it's
not. Right now, the line is just a whisker short of being completely slack, and it's
supposed to be that way, and it's going to
stay that way for just a little while longer, because they don't
need to put it in full tension yet, and instead it's just sort of making sure things don't go trying to
get away from them, and there's people all over the place on the platforming up there
watching, each one with a
specific thing they're tasked with making damn good and sure does NOT go wrong as the lift slowly proceeds, does NOT interfere in some way, and does NOT make Bad Contact in Bad Places, causing Bad Things to happen...
And the Canister's
Guide Shoes, which are supported by the Outriggers, which are firmly fixed to the forward end of the Canister, start drifting
straight up, closing in on the bottom of the Canister Guide Rails from beneath them, slowly, creepingly, but also
irresistibly, and they do NOT want to get mixed up with the bottom end of those Guide Rails
the wrong way.
And we have encountered the Canister Guide Rails a million times already, but above and beyond advising that it's
important, I've never actually told you exactly what they do or how they work.
So ok, so here we go with the Canister Guide
Rails, which we have just discovered, seem to work pretty closely with the Canister Guide
Shoes.
And it's the Guide Rails that
force the Canister into the correct position at every step along the way as it's on its way upward, by tightly-constraining the location of the Guide Shoes which are
firmly attached to the Canister through the Outriggers, preventing it from
swaying, or
twisting, on the way up, after our little winches have been unhooked from it, and then, once it's all the way up, keeping it firmly fixed in place at the exact correct distance from the Payload Changeout Room, and the Payload Ground Handling Mechanism within it, and owing to
the nature of lifts, and also
the nature of rigging, although you might
think you'd want to just set it all at the exact correct places
to start with, and then just...
pick it up, and be done with it, but of course
that's not how things work, and that
is how people who
think they know, but
don't, get themselves into
real trouble when the
real world comes knocking at their doors.
We've already covered the business of how
large suspended loads will, whether you want them to or not,
move around on you, and they can move in more than one way, and while they're in suspension, you
must account for this, or face the consequences when it all goes horribly
wrong on you. When you're doing your heavy lift
outdoors, which we very definitely
are with the Canister, the suspended load
tends to be
here or
there, but it's never
exactly here or there. It'll be close, and it may periodically
pass through here or there, but it will never
stay there. It never stops drifting around, even if only just a very little bit, but even just a very little bit can have
terrifying consequences
if it gets away from you.
And of course the Canister obeys all the laws of Suspended Loads,
and they know it, and instead of shooting for impossible-to-achieve (and also very-likely-to-fail in some unexpectedly nasty way) false accuracy,
they put a little bias
into things, and with deliberate intent,
they lift the Canister just a little too far away from the RSS. Just a little too far away from the PCR.
The centerline of the Lifting Sheaves on the 90-Hoist is "mislocated", slightly away
from the RSS.
The head sheaves on the 90-ton Hoist are not even in the "right" place!
And even if the Canister hung with a perfectly vertical alignment, perfectly straight-up-and-down, with its Lifting Trunnions perfectly centered,
it would still be in the "wrong" place, just a wee little bit too far away from the RSS.
And in so doing, they've fixed things up with the centerline of the Lifting Gear such that no matter what kind of
excursion they might wind up
getting, when they first start lifting the Canister, it's
always going to be just a weency bit too far away,
and right there is where our little red winches come into play.
They use those winches to
tug on the Canister. One on each side. Working
together. To keep the Canister from wagging around all over the goddamned place as the Guide Shoes are closing in on the bottom of the Guide Rails.
The main Lifting Gear is all centered up
slightly too far away, so whenever the Canister is
exactly where it belongs, exactly
where they want it to be, it's
always going to be
pulling against those winches. It's always going to be keeping good and sufficient
tension on any winch lines you might be using to keep it exactly where you want it, as the force of gravity causes it to continuously try to return to its natural position,
plumb, directly beneath the centerline of the Lifting Gear, which means the winch never goes slack, and they never lose
precision control of exactly where the Canister
is.
And they want to be doing this by
pulling because there's no reasonable, practical, economical, or sane, way to
push on the goddamned thing, and so they fix it up so as they'll
always be in tension with those winches, and excursions bedamned, when it's time to get those Guide Shoes
exactly where they're supposed to be, as they enter the
very-confined opening space at the bottom of their respective Guide Rails, with sub-sixteenth inch accuracy if they want it, they'll work those winches like a virtuoso works a violin, to
make it happen.
And yet another sneaky piece of interestingness occurs with the winches in
tension, pulling on the Canister
together. That tension not only pulls the Canister
toward the RSS, but it also wants to
center the Canister as it does so, too. So you wind up getting a little
side-to-side control, just by virtue of exercising some
front-to-back tension. Heavy lifts are funny things. There's a
lot more going on with them than you might at first imagine.
And by god the Guide Shoes are going to enter the bottom of the Guide Rails,
exactly where they're supposed to, despite the fact that we're hanging there
in free suspension with
nothing to keep us in place, and the Canister is sixty-five fucking feet tall and weighs one-hundred and forty fucking
thousand pounds, and
the wind is trying to blow it around all over the place (Are
you gonna be the guy to impact the
launch schedule by stopping the
lift and telling 'em to wait until a calm day comes along with no breeze?) as you're closing in on the bottom of the Guide Rails with your Guide Shoes. And breeze or no, they
make it happen. And of course, from there on up, the Guide Rails are there to keep things in line, so once they get the Shoes into the Rails, they unhook the little red winches, and "get up on it" with the big 90-ton Hoist.
And the
whole deal kind of looks like this, with good old M-143 doctored up to show things with the Canister at the instant it breaks contact with the Transporter and goes into free suspension, and again once its up a little higher, with the Guide Shoe safely enclosed within the flanges of the Guide Rail, at the point where they're just about to unhook our little red winches, which once again have done a sterling job, and all's well in Shuttleland. And Canisterland too.
Just by way of a little more help in visualizing this stuff,
here's a photograph of the Canister being lifted, and it's in an
intermediate position between the two positions I just showed you on our
altered copy of M-143, and it's very definitely off the ground in free suspension with the big Connecting Cables coming down off the Spreader Bar attached to the Forward Lifting Trunnions, and the Winch Lines are attached, too, but they're still slack, and the Guide Shoe has yet to reach the elevation of the bottom of the Guide Rail, and they're just about to pull it in toward the RSS using the Winch Lines to get it all aligned
just so, but they haven't quite gotten to that point yet.
And now that you finally have a proper
feel for just how
touchy things are, with getting the Guide Shoes into the bottoms of the Guide Rails, take a look at
our photograph from Page 32 (image number 033, Left OMS Pod Cutouts Area) once again, with a new pair of eyes, and that's an impossibly
busy image, and I'm not going to torture you with it, and instead I'm going to alter the
picture, too, to get rid of that whole PBK & Contingency Platforms mess, that's almost,
but not quite blocking our view of yet another fascinating little detail regarding what we're dealing with here.
And here's
image 033 without that whole PBK mess hanging out there off the front of the RSS and confusing the hell out of us.
And how about that! There sits
the bottom of the Guide Rail! Completely unasked for. Viewed from a
perfect direction to show you what I'm about to show you. Holy shit!
We need to stop. Right here. And
consider.
How much
more stuff is there,
completely hidden in plain sight, that we've been blissfully unaware of as we've been going through all of these photographs?
It beggars the imagination.
And it also stands as a signal warning that we can be
staring right at stuff for interminable amounts of time, and
still never see any
of it.
And then maybe stop to consider
what else is sitting right there,
hidden in plain sight, all around you,
right now!
It can give you a cold shiver when you
really think about it.
Ok. Enough of that. Back to the bottom of the Guide Rail in image 033.
Here it is zoomed-in on the altered photograph, image 033, with a label to tell you exactly where it is. Be sure and go back to the original photograph,
033, to compare things, ok? It helps a lot to have the
context, and also know
exactly what to be looking at
within that context.
And when we were back there in Part 1, on a different page,
Page 37, and we were
looking down from the Left Vehicle Access Platform at elevation 191'-0", as part of my walking you around through things, I showed you
a drawing which gives us the Guide Rail in pretty good detail,
but I didn't really explain any of it, and without an explanation you cannot have ever been expected to actually
understand all of what you were seeing, and
what it actually meant, and now I'm going to take you to that drawing again, but this time our focus is on the bottom end of the Guide Rail, and the peculiarity of how the extreme bottom end of that W10x49 has been configured.
So
here's M-79 again, highlighted to draw your attention to the bottom of the Guide Rail.
And now we know what they did to the bottom of the column,
here's that exact same place on the altered photograph, nicely-labeled for you, to give you full understanding of the clipped flange at the bottom of the Guide Rail which they cut and ground off the hard edges of the steel around, to permit
a more-forgiving
horizontal entry
of the Guide Shoe into the Guide Rail
as the Canister is being pulled inward
toward the RSS by our little red winch,
after the 90-ton Hoist has temporarily
stopped pulling it upward, until
the leading end of the Guide Shoe is correctly and
completely inside the mouth of the
Guide Rail down at its extreme bottom end, at which point the lift can
proceed upward once again.
Pretty radical, huh?
Who knew,
this much stuff had to go on,
perfectly orchestrated beneath the sky,
out in the weather, every time they wanted to get that damned Canister into place up against the face of the RSS?
And of course,
we're not even there yet.
We only just got the damned Guide Shoe into the far bottom end of the Guide Rail.
We're not done yet!
Ok. Now what?
Now it's time for the Canister to be lifted another sixty feet, roughly, until the Guide Shoes have reached the upper end of their length of travel along the Guide Rail, and it's time to get the Canister all nice and settled-in, up where it's able to do its job and disgorge its payload(s) into the innards of the PCR by handing 'em off to the PGHM.
And once we're
all the way up, we're still not in a particularly
stable configuration, because right now
the 90-ton Hoist is all that's holding us up, and if you know what's good for you, you will
never use a hoist to provide any kind of
static support for your
suspended load.
No.
Don't do that.
You're gonna kill somebody and
tear the whole place up if you do that.
You
must transfer the full weight of your suspended load from the hoist to a dedicated
static support, and I don't care
how good the brakes on your hoist are, and I don't care
how good the locking pins on your hoist are, and you're
going to transfer that load.
Period.
You go research this stuff if you want to.
You go find out how things can
go wrong when loads that are suspended for
static operations remain suspended from devices that are solely intended for
dynamic operations.
You're the guy who don't know diddly-shit about lifts. Not me.
You go figure it out.
So ok, so how'd they do it?
And we very quickly discover that
we've already been here before.
Back on
Page 30 when we were poking around on the Antenna Access Platform
down below the RCS Room.
And with the use of a few "normal" drawings, and a few heavily-doctored up drawings here and there, let us now look at things a little closer than we did before,
now that the Canister is up here, and we're gonna need to
transfer the load, and since we are now
this far in, we may as well keep right on stroking, and give the whole 90-ton Hoist SYSTEM a good close looking-at so as we can really
understand all this stuff.
So let's go look at the 90-ton Hoist.
And we've seen it a hundred times already, but let's look at it one more time, just to refamiliarize with it, and to do so, we'll use a delightfully-uncluttered and simplified Pad A
electrical drawing of all things (Pad A... elevations... remember?) to look at it in "profile" and that way we can see
all the main players, hoist, line, head sheaves, load block, and hook, without a bunch of other stuff cluttering the place up and confusing us. Be advised that the part of this drawing that we're looking at is much more of a "concept drawing" than an actual "as-built drawing", and for the moment, we
like that, because even though each individual component isn't rendered
exactly the way things wound up being furnished and installed out on the Pad, their overall
sense, locations, and interrelationships are rendered
perfectly.
So ok. So here's the
90-ton Hoist.
And
here it is again, in its natural home, up on top of the RSS, on one of the Pad A 79K04400 drawings and... elevations.
Please notice, the hook as depicted on this drawing is not what we actually wound up with at the Pad. And of course this drawing was deliberately selected because of what's
missing, and what's missing is the pair of Canister Stowage Link boom pendants, and the Spreader Bar that gets carried by the hook.
We'll return to that stuff pretty quick, but for now, it's easier to visualize things up here in the RCS Room without 'em.
So ok, so now a doctored-up drawing showing us what it looks like up here with the Canister still supported by the Hoist, and I'm very consciously and very deliberately removing the Canister Stowage Link boom pendants, because they're too-confusingly in the way, and they make it near impossible to
see this stuff as it actually gets used, and I'm also removing
the entire RCS Room Floor and Mezzanine Deck, too, for the same reason, and then on top of all that, I'm pasting in the Hoist Load Block from a different drawing, just to give it a bit more real-world fidelity.
And once all that gets done,
here's what it looks like with the 90-ton Hoist holding up the Spreader Bar, which holds up the Connecting Cables, which attach to the Forward Lifting Trunnions, which the Canister is hanging from in suspension, ready to be handed off to the Canister Stowage Links boom pendants for
static support.
And now that the Canister, and the Spreader Bar along with it, is at its proper final elevation, a member of the High Crew can tie off, and then get out there to where the Stowage Links connect to the Spreader Bar, remove the 5"Ø pin from the spelter socket (careful now, whatever the hell you do,
don't drop that thing, 'cause it's
heavy, and it'll go right
through whatever it lands on), fit the spelter socket over the lifting lug on the Spreader Bar, and then put the pin back in it and secure the pin, and now we're ready to
carry a load.
And the person down below on the Control Station for the Hoist is given the signal, and
lets the hoist down, just a little bit, until, with a few more creaks and pings and maybe a pop or two, the Stowage Links are now bearing the
entire load, and the lines from the Hoist Hook to the Spreader Bar have gone just a little bit slack, and now,
finally we're ready to use those two goddamned stupid little red winches (the ones that
started all this, remember?) down there at the bottom of things, and hook 'em on to the bottom of the Canister, and then
suck the bottom of that goddamned Canister back in to the face of the RSS for once and for all, and get the damn thing
locked in place, and now, "Mother may I?" can we get to work on our
Payload?
Please?
Yes you may, but I need to check your work with the Winches and the Stabilizing Braces before I give you the final go-ahead.
And before we go look at the Winches and the Stabilizing Braces, which are a surprisingly complicated (although
everything with the Canister Hoisting System is "surprisingly" complicated, and when are we going to quit being surprised by this stuff, anyway?) set of ratchet turnbuckles, let's see what things look like up top, with the Stowage Links connected to the Spreader Bar which is still, and will remain so for the duration, holding up the Canister via the Connecting Cables hanging down from it to the Forward Lifting Trunnions, on the poor drawing that I continuously keep beating on, doctoring it up, which now has had the
Hoist removed for clarity, in addition to all the other stuff I've previously wiped out.
And once all that gets done,
here's what it looks like with the Canister Stowage Links holding up the Spreader Bar, which holds up the Connecting Cables, which attach to the Forward Lifting Trunnions, which the Canister is hanging from in suspension, ready to be sucked in to the face of the tower down on its bottom end, using our marvelous little red winches to do so.
Phew!
And here's
the original version of M-143 once again, just so you can compare things as I've doctored them up, with the original, undoctored drawing, which is showing you what things look like, over on the right-hand side, with the Stowage Links carrying the load, and the Hoist still hooked on, slack, and the reason they leave it hooked on is because unhooking it is yet
more work, and haven't we done enough already? And also, god forbid, if something was to go badly wrong with the Stowage Links (and don't go asking "How?", because it's enough to know that Murphy, and his entire team of lawyers, got there first, and
they'll find a way if they can), we've got that Hoist all nice and hooked up too, and hopefully,
please, it will keep that goddamned Canister and whatever (and maybe
whoever) is inside of it, from
going to the ground.
So we leave well enough alone with that Hoist hooked to the Spreader Bar, ok? It's doing fine, right where it is. Leave it the fuck alone.
Keep in mind of course, at this stage of the lifting operation, that the bottom end of the Canister is
still sticking out away from the face of the RSS as it continues to dangle freely, held up
only by its Lifting Trunnions, which Lifting Trunnions, please remember, are
off center, and something's gotta be done about that with our Winches.
And here's what
that looks like, on our good friend (doctored up yet again, a different way)
M-143.
And for those of you have been following all of this
closely, there should be an
immediate question in your minds centered on the business of
access.
As in, "If we used the Canister Access Flip-up Platform to give ourselves access to the
top of the Canister to hook the Winch Lines on to the 5-foot Slings coming off the bottom ends of the big Connecting Cables that attached to the Forward Lifting Trunnions on the Canister, and now the top of the Canister is over 65 feet
above us somewhere around elevation 198' in the
lifted position in a place where the Access Flip-up down here at 125' can never give us access to anymore,
how the hell are we supposed to take those same Winch Lines and get 'em connected to the BOTTOM of the Canister?"
Glad you asked.
I'll show it to you, and in this image, the Canister is
exactly where I just showed it to you on the most-recent doctored-up version of M-143, fully lifted, but not yet rotated around to properly-vertical, still requiring the services of our Winch Lines to pull it in toward the RSS down on its bottom end. Same. Place. Exactly.
And of course that's no help at all, and it's going to need more than just a little bit of further elaboration, and as with everything else out here, there's a story inside the story, with yet
another story inside of that, and since we're here, we may as well
lean-in to it.
I previously mentioned about how
radically the Pad got modified after I had departed, and what you're seeing in this image (and many other NASA public domain images, too) is showing
things that bear no resemblance to what I'm giving to you in my own photographs as well as
the drawings I'm using to help you understand all this.
You glance at this stuff, and yeah, ok, sure, it's not exactly the same, but it's close enough.
Maybe.
Maybe not.
And you start drilling down into things,
looking closely, and all of a sudden, you discover that
it's completely different, and a hell of a lot of what I'm talking about is nowhere to be seen on these NASA photographs.
And we've entered a zone where that is true to an extraordinary degree,
and it will trip you up if you let it, and yes, things are very much so
different, but even with those very extensive differences,
the sense of the thing still stands, and the system, although altered greatly as the Pad continued to undergo extensive modifications over time, continued to
operate in pretty much the exact same manner.
And down here in the lower reaches of the RSS,
things changed, and one of the things that changed the most, is
the whole APU Access Platforming area at 125'-0" and all the hardware that they're using in that area.
In fact,
here's that photograph once again, the one with the Canister lifted, but not yet rotated around to fully-vertical, and ok... just you even
find the 125'-0" steel.
Any of it.
I'll wait right here for you.
Ok, how'd you do with it?
Did you find
any of it?
Perhaps.
Perhaps not.
So ok, so let's dig in, shall we?
There's stuff going on down there that
we need to know, and we're never going to know any of it until we can simply
find it first.
And I'm going to
go at our NASA photograph, to
show you where stuff is, so that you can
know it.
So once again,
how did they get those Winch Lines on the BOTTOM of the Canister, anyway?
And we
zoom in on our photograph to learn how.
And as with everything else around this place,
once we start digging, we realize that what at first appeared to be more-than-sufficient size and detail, has now become
insufficient, so I'm going to have to
go at our zoomed-in crop, and not only make it
larger, but also attempt to sharpen it up as I do so, so as the things that
are plainly visible to me will become
visible enough for you.
Make no mistake about it. It's a
really good picture, and it's got
everything, but it just needs a little help, ok?
So here it is, gone-at, much larger, with a bit of contrast and sharpening work applied to bring out just a little bit more detail in those places were we're going to be giving things a close look.
We'll start out by helping you orient yourself by showing you a drawing of the
Canister Access Flip-up Platform, which got moved, and completely changed into a double flip-up, the actual "access" part of which, that you walk off the end of to find yourself standing on top of the Canister, is now attached to a small flip-up "bridge" platform that spans the gap in the 125' floor steel where the Orbiter's Tail will be when the RSS is mated to it (which will of course will need to be flipped up and out of the way when that happens). And even
this is not strictly accurate and in full agreement with the
photograph, because the floor steel shown in the drawing got
completely chopped away and reworked at some point, and even the
platform isn't the same, either, but enough already. Give it a rest! You can see what's going on here, and that's really all that matters right now.
And here's that completely-reworked
Canister Access Platform in the photograph, with the "access" flip-up part of it stowed, locked in its "up" position, with the "bridge" part of it still in place, spanning the gap in the 125'-0" floor steel where the Orbiter's Tail will go, with the RSS mated.
And clearly, nobody's going to be trying to use this thing to hang a couple of wire ropes on the bottom of the Canister. No. Not gonna happen.
And this whole area down here at the APU Servicing Platform, elevation 125'-0" has gotten
hairy, and
my photograph fails to match
NASA's photograph(s), and
nobody's photographs match the
drawings, and it's a hugely-complicated
mess down here, so to maybe try and help you along a little more,
I'm going to include another photograph courtesy of John A. O'Connor, which is a screenshot from a
gigapan image, taken from what is without the slightest doubt, the world's
best collection of images of not only this area, but all over the place, including the whole Pad, hosted at NASATECH.NET, and we're now looking "from the inside, out" at the same place I just showed you where I highlighted the "new" Canister Access Platform, and you can now see one of the two Winches, and it's no longer red, and it's no longer hand-operated, and it's no longer mounted on a stub column, and is instead, yellow, electric, and it's floor-mounted.
But it's the same winch and it does the same job.
It also does
more now, lots more in fact, but it's the same winch they will be using to tie to the slings which hang from the bottom of the Canister, and they're going to be
pulling the Canister in with it, and that's all well and good, but we
still don't know how in hell they managed to get the damned winch lines on the bottom of the Canister! But you've got to give me time, ok? I
will get us there.
Like I just said a minute ago, it's gotten
hairy.
Part of the hairiness consists in the fact that
the rigging, the lines they use to pull on stuff with, is
completely different from what's shown on the drawings.
And it looks (I do not know for a certain fact, because I was
gone before this final incarnation of things down here was ever
designed, nevermind furnished and installed, and I therefore must
surmise, with nothing more to go on than NASA's imagery, and John A. O'Connor's gigapans), that everything was done with a
sling (or more likely more than one sling), which connected to the winch on one end, was reeved through a snatch block or two, someplace midway along its length, and then attached at its other end to whatever might have needed some force applied to it for lifting, lowering, or just pulling.
And I'm going to
presume that there was a
dedicated sling, having a single snatch block on it, which was used to pull the bottom of the Canister all the way back to the face of the RSS, and for the purposes of subsequent discussion, I'm going to call that presumptive sling the "Tugger Sling." And we all know I'm just
making this shit up, and if this sling existed in the first place as a single dedicated-use piece of hardware, it
surely had a different name, but... we're missing stuff. We wish we had
just a little more information, but we do not, and in its absence, in order to keep sensible
track of things, we're forced to use our own made-up nomenclature.
One of my primary pieces of evidence for surmising that it was all done with a sling is visible on the gigapan (thanks John, you're the best) frame in the form of multiple
shackles hanging down from overhead, only two pairs of which are at the moment in-use, holding up the snatch blocks, which are carrying what I believe to be a/the sling, which is attached to the small flip-up platform with the funny-looking angled end (which gives access to the little nook in between the OMS Pod and the base of the Orbiter's Tail) on one end, and reeves through the snatch blocks up and across to another (hidden) shackle on the far side of the RSS Main Framing Pipe (part of the Column Line B Primary Structural Framing that Wilhoit erected all those years ago, and the shadows of Dick Walls, Cecil Wilhoit, Tom Kirby, Red Milliken, and the very best Union Ironworkers that Local 808 had to offer can still be seen faintly hovering in the air out at the far corners of your peripheral vision if you look for them
just-so), and that pipe with the hidden shackle on it is none too far from the winch itself, and it would be easy enough (actually, it would be
ideal) to hook the end of the winch line to the sling from over there, and that sling is where you see it, because it's
stowed, and Pad A had already been
abandoned when John O'Connor was granted permission to come and get gigapans of the whole place
before they tore it down, and the
last place that sling wound up was in it's
stowed location, before it
disappeared from the face of the earth forever.
And we'll use
John O'Connor's gigapan frame one more time, to show you what I mean.
We wish we had
more to work with, and
we know for a fact that there
is more to work with, but somebody is
sitting on it, and for now,
this is all we're ever going to get.
Note: NASA and other Great Bureaucracies (and I'm looking directly at
YOU Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum) seem to have not only
no interest in the fine-grained detail of the
historical aspects to all of this, but also appear to be curated by breathtakingly stiff-necked and high-handed people who are solely concerned with self-aggrandizement and their own personal and narrowly-defined
control over things.
They are not
team players. They are not going to help. They are not going to help
you, and they are not going to help
anybody else.
You've probably met a few of these
creatures yourselves, a time or two over the course of your life. Perhaps in a wood-paneled office sitting behind a mahogany desk, perhaps somewhere else.
These are the deeply-unpleasant (but ever-so-
polite), too-formal, too-brittle, people dressed in power suits who
despise "unofficial" agencies and individuals, and they know they will never be able to
control (nevermind the fact that it's
our bootprints on that fucking steel, and very definitely not
theirs, and now that I think about it this is probably one of the
primary reasons for the despisement because in their secret hearts they
know that they're lame outsiders,
losers, who were never
involved and who could never have hacked it in the extraordinarily high-pressure high-risk high-stakes high-skill-level environment working with the hardware
hands-on, and those of us who can
get it done make them look
bad by comparison) those of us who are "unaffiliated" and whose only desire is to add to the pitiful store of accurate historical documentation of things, and they would
destroy it all by throwing endless Kafkaesque roadblocks in the way of those
unaffiliated persons and agencies whose mission is the increase and diffusion of
knowledge.
There are some
nasty people sitting behind some of those desks, and some of them are located at the very highest levels. Be warned.
Screw those assholes. Let's get back to the
Launch Pad. Let's get back to
making it happen.
So anyway, I'm gonna
lean-in to it, and I'm going to label up the zoomed in NASA image of this area, and I'm going to call things like I see 'em, and if I'm wrong, I can only hope that one of the people who actually
used this stuff, or maybe one of the people who
designed it, will see any mistakes I've made, and take the time and effort to contact me and
correct me.
So ok. So here we go.
And returning to our NASA photograph, the one I enlarged and enhanced a little bit,
here it all is, nicely-labeled so you can locate and identify all the players in this little tableau.
Sure thing. Whatever you say, MacLaren.
Well wait a minute. I can explain.
Ok, go right ahead and
explain, then.
Pick the tilted Canister up.
Lift the tilted Canister to its final elevation.
Hook the lines on to the bottom of the tilted Canister and
suck it in to the face of the RSS.
Lock the no-longer-tilted Canister in place.
Proceed with work on your
payload operations.
Nothing to it.
And we have seen, on that
ridiculous marked-up NASA photograph I just showed you, the one that looks too-much like an old Geocities web page from the 1990's (but at least there's no animated gifs in there), that they use
the PBK Platforms (located at elevation 133'-9" which makes them unusable for gaining access to the
top of the Canister prior to the lift) to gain access to the Lower Canister Attach Slings that went up into the air along with the Canister when they first
lifted it.
And by means of this access to those Lower Canister Attach Slings on both sides, somebody from over on the main body of the RSS tosses a
messenger line to whoever's over there on the PBK Platform, and the messenger line is tied to the snatch block on the "Tugger Sling" which is hooked in a big loop from the shackle on the Main Framing Pipe, out, around, and back to the Winch, and the person on the PBK Platform pulls in the messenger line, and in so doing pulls in the
snatch block, and once the snatch block and the Lower Canister Attach Sling are
both over there on the PBK Platform, the Lower Canister Attach Sling gets hooked to the snatch block, and now we're ready to wind the winches and suck the bottom of the Canister all the way back to the face of the RSS.
And go back and look at that marked-up NASA photograph once again, if you need to, and lo-and-behold, there it all is in plain sight, complete all the way down to the fine detail of the technician on the PBK Platform getting ready to hook the Sling to the snatch block.
It's all there.
Every last bit of it.
In a
single image.
Which is pretty cool, if you ask me.
Very well then, we've finally gotten the Canister pulled all the way in to the face of the RSS, and it's now in its final working position, let's get it locked in place, ok?
With
these things.
Ratchet turnbuckles.
Nice
heavy ratchet turnbuckles.
And I mentioned a pretty good while ago that it was "surprisingly" complicated, and the merest glance at the drawing will confirm that, and we find ourselves wondering... how the hell did
this stuff work, anyway?
And they cut a
slot in the Guide Rail flange, over on the side of things away from where the Guide Shoe would be running vertically up and down, and of course then they had to slap a nice heavy ¾" plate face-down going
around the slot in the flange, to beef up the W10x49 where they just
put a hole in it, and which is also where the
load from the Canister would be getting applied by the Stabilizing Braces, and then once they were happy with that, they welded a pair of half-inch plates running flange-to-flange inside the W10, separated by ⅞", with the gap between them matching the location of the slot they cut into the flange, and then they came up with a system that employed
two big heavy ratchet turnbuckles which both attached to a removable ¾" plate made out of
A588 steel, which is some of the weirdest "
stainless" steel you can find, and and that A588 plate slid through the slot in between the two half-inch plates welded inside the flanges of the W10, and now
that thing needs to get held firmly in place, so how 'bout a pair of 1"Ø detent pins, and of course there's a risk of dropping them, so they both get their own steel wire lanyards, and this thing is starting to snowball on us, and we haven't even gotten to the
ratchet turnbuckles yet, and...
Yeeks. Nothing's easy. Nothing's simple. Everything's connected to
everything, and when you touch
any of it, you wind up touching
all of it, and...
It gets
hairy.
And the turnbuckles came as a pair, at each attach point on the Canister, and with the two turnbuckles forming a nice stiff structural
triangle, and having the ability to be
ratcheted down, applying significant
tension on the two legs of the triangle that ran from the side of the Canister back to that half-inch plate stuffed up in there on the back side of the Guide Rail which they're both attached to simultaneously, all of a sudden,
none of this stuff is ever gonna be going ANYwhere, and of course for things whose job it is to be
locking something else... well then, that's
exactly what we want.
And that's exactly what we
get.
And of course with the turnbuckles, there's additional
hairiness, 'cause the damn things are
heavy (Careful there Lou, don't be letting that thing get away from you, and don't let it
go over the side on you.) there exists the need for yet another...
turnbuckle!Holy shit, a turnbuckle for the
turnbuckle? No way!
Yes way.
A turnbuckle for the turnbuckle. On a lanyard.
And if it's
you that's up there in the cold wind and the rain trying to wrestle this stuff on to the tie-lugs on the Canister without dropping something and killing somebody with it or maybe poking a hole in the Canister somehow, you're gonna be very happy to
have that nice sturdy lanyard with a fine-adjustment turnbuckle for your turnbuckle to hold the damn thing properly and accurately in place as you work the detent pin over on the Canister side of things, or otherwise wrestling this thing into place becomes a much less cheerful operation, and... yeah.
And you'd be
very exposed to the elements as you were performing this little task.
This was very definitely an
all-weather operation.
And there were four places
which we can see here on poor old beat-up M-149, out there on the face of the RSS, where they locked the Canister in place, and of course each of those places had the pair of vertical C4x5.4's with all the fixin's that you can see in
Detail C on M-164, to keep everything right where it belonged, which is where the heavy turnbuckles and all the rest of it would be securely placed when not in use, and here we are here, with those locations.
And you'd get to 'em high,
up on the Vehicle Access Platforms at elevation 191'-0".
And you'd get to 'em low,
down on the PBK Platform.
Both of which places we've already been to before, more than once, even, and isn't this enough already?
Is the Canister ready to be handed over to the payloads people?
Finally?
Yes it is.
Finally.
Our work here is done.
You may go home now.
And pour yourself a couple of cold ones.
You've earned it.